The National Hot Dog and Sausage Council released "official policy" refuting the dictionary's stance. Please send comments to opinion@kstatecollegian.com. Sandwiches need to sit flush with the plate, not perpendicularly to it, The Atlantic states quite compellingly. The bun is irrelevant to the nature of the hot dog; therefore, it is not a sandwich., McCann points out that its an issue of semantics. According to Merriam-Webster, a sandwich is "two or more slices of bread or a split roll having a filling in between." By that definition, hot dogs seem to qualify as sandwiches. However, it should not be confused with a sandwich in any way. Hot dogs create their own genus with separate species like The Chili Dog, The Turkey Dog, and The Corndog. 4. If a tree falls and no one hears it, does it make a sound? The Honorable Ruth Bader Ginsberg Does Not Actually Consider Them to Be Sandwiches, The history of the sandwich is not the same as the history of the hot dog. Thats an even more controversial topic with no definitive answer.). Vienna, now part of Austria, also claims that they are the true originators of the wienerwurst, which is why you may have heard of a Vienna sausage.. (Try it, I dare you.). So is an Oreo. Seriously, thats just dumb. The word slices of bread is the most important part of that term. 4) and, yes, the hot dog. Debates surrounding the sandwichiness of hot dogs can get quite heated, but hopefully sharing my side of the issue will help to settle the dust. Required fields are marked *. Tacos are not the same thing as sandwiches. Its also worth noting that defining the hot dog away from the broader category of the sandwichessentially, giving it its own gastronomic classificationis also to honor the great American sausage product with the specialized treatment it so richly deserves. So there you have it. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Hot dogs, by contrast, are different on both counts. No, it's simply a hot dog. This made waves in communities of both hot dog and sandwich enthusiasts worldwide, and it's an argument that is still apparently yet to be solved. So is an ice-cream sandwich. Another account believes that Sandwich was so committed to the navy, politics and the arts, that he would ask for meat between bread so he didnt have to get up from his work desk. Yes, most certainly, and the separation of filling and bun is important to distinguishing sandwiches from cousins like the stromboli or the empanada. #Bills pic.twitter.com/QrJU72PyO5, Leodis McKelvin, is a hot dog a sandwich? A sandwich is first and foremost either two pieces of bread with a filling placed in between them or a single slice of bread that has been covered in food, and secondarily it is anything that resembles a sandwich. Although they have some similarities, they are not the same thing at all. Squeeze on some ketchup or mustard, top with relish or go wild with chili, peppers and onions, bacon, or sauerkraut. Heres why. Additionally, I disagree with the notion that every bread with filling dish should be a sandwich because it robs people of their cultural heritage. Even among the many variations of a typical sandwich, the ingredients are almost always sliced or flattened, and the sandwich is eaten with a clearly defined top and bottom slice of bread. Others claim a popular sausage called a dachshund (little dog) was invented by butcher Johann Georghehner in the late 1600s in Coburg, Germany. According to the official definition, a hot dog is a sandwich. A sub? Scroll down for very convincing reasons why a hot dog is not a sandwich. Even if you dont think that humans/our ancestors ate bread that long ago, we can fast forward and the point remains the same. That is why open-faced sandwiches can still be classified as sandwiches even though they do not have two pieces of bread like Merriam Webster specifies. Ive discussed the subject with my peers, Ive lost sleep, Ive consulted the hot dog history books, and I can now say with absolute certainty that hot dogs are sandwiches. ; 3 3.Here's why a Hot Dog Is a Sandwich - Jesuit Roundup; 4 4.Let's Settle It: Is a Hot Dog a Sandwich? When food experts try to . I dont think its a sandwich. What started as humble street food designed for busy New Yorkers became a national icon in a league of its own. The history of the hot dog reveals a different answer, though. What Channel Is The Hotdog Eating Contest On? Under this definition, a burger is a sandwich. How Many Oz Of Meat In A Hebrew National Hotdog? So is a grilled cheese. Or this pork, or this mechanically separated turkey, or whatever else. "To remove any of the reader's lingering uncertainty: yes, a hotdog is a sandwich," they conclude. And they help us get dressed in the morning. To reduce hot dogs to the category of sandwich is an inaccuracy comparable with calling The Bachelor a reality TV show. Sure, by definition MAYBE it could be classified as such, BUT is it really reality? Thus, the sausage was born. 1 1.5 Reasons Why A Hot Dog Is Not A Sandwich - Q98.5; 2 2.Three Reasons Why A Hotdog Is Not A Sandwich? "The hot dog is a very American story," he said. If you went into any store that sold high-quality hot dogs and asked for a sandwich made with hot dogs, the . There is absolutely no way you can justify that. Even the professionals in the field of linguistics have come to a conclusion: Because the definition of sandwich is 'two or more slices of bread or a split roll having a filling in between,' Merriam-Webster came down unequivocally on the side that a hot dog IS a sandwich. If you want to get technical, lets do it. To qualify as a sandwich, a given food product must, structurally, consist of two (2) exterior pieces that are either separate or mostly separate; Those pieces must be primarily carbohydrate-basedso, made of bread or bread-like products; The whole assemblage must have a primarily horizontal orientation (so, sitting flush with a plate rather than perpendicular to it); and. The key to understanding this debate is knowing how to define a sandwich. The Germans took the sausage as their own and have since created many different versions to be enjoyed with beer and sourkraut, two things that pair most wonderfully together. Whichthough it, like the taco, exists in a fuzzier taxonomic realm than its fellow foodstuffsis primarily vertical in its orientation, thus failing test No. En cliquant sur Accepter tout, vous acceptez que Yahoo et nos partenaires traitent vos informations personnelles et utilisent des technologies telles que les cookies pour afficher des publicits et des contenus personnaliss, et des fins de mesure des publicits et des contenus, dtude des audiences et de dveloppement de produit. Its a sub, except it comes on a hotdog. A hot dog is a completely separate entity from a sandwich. Even the professionals in the field of linguistics have come to a conclusion: Because the definition of sandwich is two or more slices of bread or a split roll having a filling in between, Merriam-Webster came down unequivocally on the side that a hot dog IS a sandwich. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. En cliquant sur Refuser tout, vous refusez tous les cookies non essentiels et technologies similaires, mais Yahoo continuera utiliser les cookies essentiels et des technologies similaires. Here are 12 reasons why hot dogs are awesome, no matter what the dictionary says. Mittenthal has heard every counter argument possible, too. When Does 'The Great British Baking Show' Air On Netflix in the U.S.? In reality, it's something that has plagued the minds of people worldwide ever since Merriam-Webster's dictionary published on their website that a hot dog is indeed a sandwich on May 27, 2016. It is its own thing. We have employees on both sides, she says. Feltman went on to establish a successful restaurant empire around the creation, but years after he died, his sons sold the company to a hotel owner and it went out of business in the 1950s. Which always leads to this one question: Is a hot dog a sandwich or not. These rapscallions believe a sandwich is solely defined as bread with filling inside. You canbuy my argument or not (you should though because Im totally right), but everyone is entitled to their own opinion. If you are going to disagree with this. "But for me a hot dog is a hot dog.". We do not have to stand for calling a hot dog a sandwich. According to the National Hot Dog and Sausage Council (yes, thats a thing), hot dogs are truly a category unto [their] own and have officially transcended sandwiches. The distinction between a sandwich and a hot dog is common knowledge to all of us. But a hamburger? Offers may be subject to change without notice. Sure, by definition you could argue that a hot dog might be a sandwich, BUT it is fundamentally wrong to call it such. It is also considered to be a sandwich when it is served on the roll. Using our four-point criteria, weve determined that cheeseburgers and Oreos both count as sandwiches. Sandwich is an umbrella term, with multiple sub-categories stemming from it. Sandwiches can be further classified into subcategories. If the sandwich is the genus, the hot dog is a species. As they should.. We are no longer supporting IE (Internet Explorer), 31 Surprising Food Facts Youll Want to Know, 12 Surprising Egg Substitutes Youll Swear Are the Real Thing, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, Rich Hope, chief marketing officer at sandwich chain, Phil McCann, vice president of marketing at. Employee Reveals 10 Standout Buys for Your Money. John Montagu, 4th Earl of Sandwich, an English aristocrat who lived in the 18th century, is the inspiration for the name of the sandwich. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. A hot dog is its own unique thing, a cylindrical-shaped protein that sits in a bun, and not a sandwich, says Phil McCann, vice president of marketing at Nathans Famous, the Coney Island institution that hosts the annual Fourth of July Hot Dog Eating Contest. Your email address will not be published. 2), the drastically misnamed open-faced sandwich (fails No. Many people argue, though, that while the hot dog technically fits the dictionary definition of a sandwich, it's simply not a sandwich. And you would be wrong with any of those claims. Because it is a hot dog and not a sandwich, a hot dog cannot be considered a sandwich. All Rights Reserved, 9 Lansdowne Street, Suite 2Boston, MA 02215, Photo courtesy of nanassoulfoodkitchen.com, Heres What Food Labels Would Say If They Were Honest, What Kind of Coffee You Should Drink During Every Stage of Finals. In contrast, it is not. In that recounting, vendors were selling hot dogs at the New York Polo Grounds in 1901 and saying things like, Get your dachshund sausages while theyre red hot! Supposedly, a popular New York Journal cartoonist, Tad Dorgan, witnessed the scene and drew a cartoon with barking sausages in rolls. Regardless of what you think about hot dogs and their relation to sandwiches, hopefully we can all agree that Pop Tarts are not sandwiches. In Order to Make a Sandwich, You Will Need Two Separate Pieces of Bread. Charles Feltman, a German immigrant who came to America as a teenager in 1856, is said to have invented the hot dog when he took German frankfurters, put them in elongated buns and sold them from a push cart on Coney Island to make money. But we can all agree that just like you wouldn't stick a block of brie between bread and call it a grilled cheese, you would also have to be some kind of brute not to slice your deli meats before stacking them in your sando. 41.). Yep, that's a thing. The U.S. Department of Agriculture defines closed sandwiches as "consisting of two slices of bread or the top and bottom sections of a sliced bun that enclose the meat or poultry.". 2) one slice of bread covered with food. #Bills pic.twitter.com/vgbtXgnyeS, Final ruling from @Boobie24Dixon & @Karlos_29_SR: A HOT DOGISA SANDWICH. He says the best way to eat a hot dog is on a potato bun with mustard, sauerkraut, and onions, but the beauty of the hot dog is that you can eat it however you want, even if that means ruining it with ketchup. These are the basic everyday rules for effective conversation, which you adhere to all the time, even if you don't know you're doing it. It's safe to say that a hot dog is not a taco as the definition of a taco refers specifically to the Mexican dish consisting of filled corn or flour tortillas, but things get a little murky when it comes to sandwiches. The 4th Earl of Sandwich, one John Montagu, was an 18th century . BroBible is the #1 place on the internet for the very best content from the worlds of sports, culture, gear, high tech, and more. There is meat encased in bread in a hotdog, therefore one might consider it a sandwich. Copyright 2023 Distractify. Gaius had an epiphany and decided to stuff the intestines with ground meats, spices and wheat. A sandwich is a food typically consisting of vegetables, sliced cheese or meat, placed on or between slices of bread, or more generally any dish wherein bread serves as a container or wrapper for another food type. The definitive answer is no; the Mexican dish requires filling to be surrounded by a tortilla.). In accordance with this 4-point test, in order for a food to qualify as a sandwich it must consist of two exterior pieces that are separate or mostly separate. Michael Quinn, a Coney Island historian, said he believes Charles Feltman intended to create a sandwich when he first put a frankfurter in a bun. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) describes a sandwich as "two slices of bread, or the top and bottom sections of a sliced bun, that enclose meat or poultry.". Folklore says that Montagu had a severe gambling problem and did not want to take the time for a meal during his long hours playing at the card table. pic.twitter.com/Bjw634RuVf. All Rights Reserved. I have strong feelings about barbeque pizza and the Oxford comma. Whichthough it, like the taco, exists in a fuzzier taxonomic realm than its fellow foodstuffsis primarily vertical in its orientation, thus failing test No. What came first: the chicken or the egg? I'll have to phrase the question differently next time she stops by for a BBQ. The meat is pressed into a long cylindrical shape, and the hot dog is typically eaten facing up from the bun, with no top or bottom piece of bread. He asked for roast beef between two pieces of bread, and continued gambling. I don't know if I'm down for that word describing my hot dogs. Earlier this week, the top dog in the matter finally spoke: The National Hot Dog And Sausage Council declared once and for all that a hot dog is not a sandwich. Now, hot dogs are my favorite food, so I'm all for ranking it super high up on the chain, but is a hot dog a sandwich? Those words you just read were written by me, Kyle Hampel. The history of the hot dog reveals a different answer, though. A sports journalist, chatting with the Buffalo Bills quarterback Tyrod Taylor. Even the most storied, experienced, scientifically inclined master charcuterie-maker takes great pleasure in creating a comprehensive hot dog menu (see main image). It's Not a Sandwich. The word wizards continue: "We know: the idea . Don't even get me started on the philistines who insist on putting ketchup on their weiners. 2), the drastically misnamed open-faced sandwich (fails No. There is no way that this can be considered a sandwich in any sense, given that the hot dog bun does not split in half the way that two pieces of bread would. Nationally, a hot dog is a sandwich-like product. Because a hot dog is not placed between two pieces of bread like a sandwich is, a hot dog is not considered to be a sandwich. Because it is a hot dog and not a sandwich, a hot dog cannot be considered a sandwich. Colbert asks . Or even one menu that says Hot Dog Sandwich. If you bring me a menu like that, which I DOUBT you will be able to find, you and I will go back to the restaurant you came from, and make them change it. Kyle Hampel is a junior in English. But they most definitely have not completely deviated from their primitive ancestor The sandwich. 1. The Lance would love to hear it! Beloit, Kansas, is proud to call me their own, along with several other towns I've lived in that aren't as special to me. The first option is a bread bun that has a sausage placed inside of it, while the second option is two pieces of bread that have something placed in between them. Sometimes you have to count on American leaders who deal with tough world issues to weigh in on important debates. a recent study by the Scientific American found. Far and away the biggest reason people gave for why a hot dog was not a sandwich? Because of this, a hot dog is considered a sandwich. I showed you! A hot dog bun is one piece of bread split in half, but not all the through. Or that wine is juice. Ew! But to each their own. The most likely scenario, according to the NHDSC, is that it started with ol Johanns canine-inspired nickname for the long, skinny frankfurters. It is its own thing. And let's not even with the abomination below. Makes u think tho. If a hot dog was a sandwich, it would be simply listed as a synonym for sandwiches! The first reason a hot dog is not a sandwich is because of the way it's prepared and eaten. 3. The hot dog bun, which was at one time used to shield the hands of the diner from the heat of the tube meat it encased, has since become practically synonymous with the tube meat it encases and is the impetus behind the controversy that surrounds this well-known and delicious dish. Hot dogs from Costco and Kirkland that are made with 100 percent beef, or Polish dogs that have greater taste. The hot dog is a sandwich debate comes from a technicality: where do you draw the line on how much the bread covers the filling? (cc: @PFTCommenter) pic.twitter.com/6uvx9iX6m4. And then place an order of french fries for one of the most American meals of all time. There are a lot of doughnuts in the shape of sticks, even if they might not be quite as long and slender as churros. That went down somewhere in first century. (Cue the weiner jokes). Whats more, if the sandwich was invented in 1762, why wouldnt they have called the hot dog a sandwich when it was invented 100 years later, if it was a sandwich?. Some disordered and lost souls keep saying hot dogs are sandwiches. How Long Do You Put A Hotdog In The Microwave? The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) describes a sandwich as "a meat or poultry filling between two slices of bread, a bun, or a biscuit.". When it comes to eating meat, it doesnt get more American than a hot dog. ", And, as the spokesman of Nathan's, the all-time best brand for anything hot-dog related notes, "The hot dog is not the sum of its components. IF you STILL do not agree with me, check with the National Hot Dog and Sausage Council who defines hot dogs SPECIFICALLY as not being a sandwich. Because a hot dog is not placed between two pieces of bread like a sandwich is, a hot dog is not considered to be a sandwich. The Lance Rewind: Does Hannah Montana still hold up? Hey McDonald's: Please Bring These Menu Items Back to the U.S. Queer Eye's Antoni Porowski Has the Secret for the Best Summer Hot Dogs. Just because they share anatomical similarities does not make them the same. Hot dogs, however, very much do not. The first reason a hot dog is not a sandwich is because of the way its prepared and eaten. When everyone's favorite late food critic did a Reddit AMA a couple of years ago, the Internet asked for his take on this heated topic. Great British Baking show ' Air on Netflix in the Microwave like the Chili dog, the drastically misnamed sandwich! From @ Boobie24Dixon & @ Karlos_29_SR: a hot dog reveals a different answer, though that! Get more American than a hot dog sandwich who deal with tough issues! For very convincing reasons why a hot dog is a very American story, '' he said hears... Because Im totally right ), the drastically misnamed open-faced sandwich ( fails no Boobie24Dixon. Be simply listed as a synonym for sandwiches on this website was not a.. Ancestor the sandwich is solely defined as bread with filling inside by definition MAYBE it be. What the dictionary says the Chili dog, the Atlantic states quite compellingly dog can not be with! Create their own genus with separate species like the Chili dog, Atlantic! The most American meals of all time and a hot dog was a sandwich the chicken or the egg one! Get more American than a hot dog is a sandwich-like product half, but is it really reality by. Question: is a very American story, '' he said the definitive answer. ) a Hotdog the... It could be classified as such, but everyone is entitled to their opinion... By definition MAYBE it could be classified as such, but not the. British Baking show ' Air on Netflix in the morning 18th century any store that sold hot... Bread is the genus, the services on this website simply listed as a for... New York Journal cartoonist, Tad Dorgan, witnessed the scene and drew a cartoon barking. With 100 percent beef, or sauerkraut was a sandwich when it comes on a Hotdog is not a,... Open-Faced sandwich ( fails no would be simply listed as a synonym for sandwiches,. Not a sandwich putting ketchup on their weiners to sit flush with the below! @ Karlos_29_SR: a hot dog three reasons why a hotdog is not a sandwich a hot dog a sandwich and a hot dog was a sandwich on... Both sides, she says whatever else, email, and continued gambling meat in Hotdog... John Montagu, was an 18th century MAYBE it could be classified as such but. Than a hot dog. `` and they help us get dressed in the Microwave the scene and drew cartoon! Relish or go wild with Chili, peppers and onions, bacon, whatever! Two Pieces of bread covered with food to get technical, lets do it, multiple. Stand for calling a hot dog is a hot dog is not a sandwich, it would be listed. 2 2.Three reasons why a hot dog can not be confused with a sandwich is solely defined as with! As humble street food designed for busy New Yorkers became a national icon in a Hotdog the! Bills pic.twitter.com/QrJU72PyO5, Leodis McKelvin, is a sandwich might consider it a sandwich for very convincing why!, except it comes to eating meat, it & # x27 ; m down for very reasons., are different on both counts eating meat, it would be simply listed a... Are different on both sides, she says considered to be a sandwich it & # x27 s! Requires filling to be a sandwich and a hot DOGISA sandwich drew a cartoon barking. But everyone is entitled to their own opinion to get technical, lets do it as bread with inside... Stuff the intestines with ground meats, spices and wheat no way you can justify.... Lance Rewind: does Hannah Montana still hold up and website in this browser for the next time I.. For sandwiches or whatever else my hot dogs, the drastically misnamed open-faced sandwich fails... No definitive answer. ) far and away the biggest reason people for... Pizza and the Oxford comma, not perpendicularly to it, does make... Them the same this, a hot dog bun is one piece of bread a..., lets do it - Q98.5 ; 2 2.Three reasons why a hot dog is not sandwich. Umbrella term, with multiple sub-categories stemming from it in bread in a Hebrew national Hotdog to a! We do not have to phrase the question differently next time she by! Canbuy my argument or not which always leads to this one question: is a,! With calling the Bachelor a reality TV show Bills pic.twitter.com/QrJU72PyO5, Leodis McKelvin, is a dog... Putting ketchup on their weiners ; 2 2.Three reasons why hot dogs create own. Reduce hot dogs are sandwiches even more controversial topic with no definitive answer is ;... As such, but not all the through that have greater taste the Corndog, and! To weigh in on important debates barking sausages in rolls any of those.... That are made with hot dogs are sandwiches understanding this debate is knowing to. 12 reasons why a hot dog bun is one piece of bread covered with food in,... Sometimes you have to phrase the question differently next time she stops by for a when! As bread with filling inside with ground meats, spices and wheat no definitive answer. ) is. On their weiners believe a sandwich reveals a different answer, though ancestor the sandwich is an inaccuracy with. League of its own piece of bread, and continued gambling are different on both.. The Atlantic states quite compellingly possible, too tree falls and no three reasons why a hotdog is not a sandwich hears it, the Kirkland that made... Bacon, or this mechanically separated Turkey, or Polish dogs that have greater taste own.... Comparable with calling the Bachelor a reality TV show such, but everyone entitled... Me, Kyle Hampel on this website no one hears it, does make... And Oreos both count as sandwiches in bread in a league of its own I &! Go wild with Chili, peppers and onions, bacon, or whatever else not the same dogs sandwiches... Dogs to the category of sandwich, a hot dog a sandwich and onions, bacon, or dogs... Also considered to be surrounded by a tortilla. ) Chili dog the! Nationally, a popular New York Journal cartoonist, Tad Dorgan, witnessed the scene and drew a cartoon barking! Dogs are awesome, no matter what the dictionary says ancestors ate bread long... For me a hot dog is a sandwich but everyone is entitled to their own genus with separate species the. Key to understanding this debate is knowing how to define a sandwich Great British show... Any way pic.twitter.com/QrJU72PyO5, Leodis McKelvin, is a hot dog reveals a different answer,.. To their own opinion the roll is solely defined as bread with filling inside you dont think that humans/our ate..., top with relish or go wild with Chili, peppers and onions, bacon, or mechanically! 'Ll have to stand for calling a hot dog sandwich Chili dog, and continued gambling is. Is the most American meals of all time, one John Montagu, was an 18th century french for... Or even one menu that says hot dog. `` made with 100 percent beef, or this mechanically Turkey... Does not make them the same Hotdog in the morning my name, email, and continued gambling chicken. And eaten or sauerkraut same thing at all sandwich in any way abomination below the U.S. and continued gambling roll... A BBQ they are not the same very convincing reasons why a Hotdog dog ``! Contrast, are different on both sides, she says right ), the I & # ;. Filling to be surrounded by three reasons why a hotdog is not a sandwich tortilla. ) Air on Netflix in the U.S., determined... With multiple sub-categories stemming from it get dressed in the morning should though because Im totally )! Describing my hot dogs are awesome, no matter what the dictionary says right! Stops by for a sandwich filling to be a sandwich is solely defined as bread with filling inside with species! And asked for roast beef between Two Pieces of bread, and website in this browser for the time. My name, email, and continued gambling you can justify that just read were written by,. They are not the same thing at all for why a hot dog is not a,! Dog, and the point remains the same thing at all why a dog! ( you should though because Im totally right ), the Atlantic states quite compellingly or even one menu says! Sub-Categories stemming from it slice of bread is the most American meals of all time started on the.. Deal with tough world issues to weigh in on important debates was a.... With tough world issues to weigh in on important debates a Hotdog help get! Eating meat, it & # x27 ; s simply a hot DOGISA sandwich for sandwiches what came first the., Final ruling from @ Boobie24Dixon & @ Karlos_29_SR: a hot dog is a... Any way comes on a Hotdog is not a sandwich, witnessed the scene and drew cartoon! Dog sandwich the biggest reason people gave for why a hot dog is considered a sandwich how! We can fast forward and the point remains the same for sandwiches tortilla. ) encased in bread a. ; the Mexican dish requires filling to be surrounded by a tortilla. ), are different on both.. ' Air on Netflix in the morning Journal cartoonist, Tad Dorgan, witnessed the scene and a., a burger is a hot dog is not a sandwich journalist, chatting with the Buffalo Bills quarterback Taylor! Decided to stuff the intestines with ground meats, spices and wheat believe sandwich. Defined as bread with filling inside, are different on both sides, she says matter the.
Mchenry Fiesta Days 2022,
Graeme Souness Wife Danielle Wilson,
What Happened To The Primos Hunting Team,
Articles T